The Khabar staff would like to thank you for your readership, comments and contributions. Khabar will discontinue its service on 20 March 2015.

Intolerance a key issue in West Java election

As voters wait for official results of the polling, the governor's last-minute deal with a hardline group raises questions.

By Hanny Hermawan for Khabar Southeast Asia in Tangerang West Java

March 01, 2013
Reset Text smaller larger

Residents of West Java say they want their next governor to tackle rising intolerance and religious violence in the province, rated worst in Indonesia in that regard.

  • A man casts his ballot in West Java's gubernatorial election in Tasikmalaya on February 24th. West Java residents are hoping their political leader will curb religious violence in the region. [Timur Matahari/AFP].

    A man casts his ballot in West Java's gubernatorial election in Tasikmalaya on February 24th. West Java residents are hoping their political leader will curb religious violence in the region. [Timur Matahari/AFP].

The province is awaiting official results of its February 24th gubernatorial election, to be announced March 3rd by the General Election Commission (Komisi Pemilihan Umum/KPU).

Quick count results conducted by the Indonesian Survey Institute (LSI) suggest that incumbent Ahmad Heryawan has won a second five-year term, taking more than 30% of the vote and avoiding a second round. Aher, as he is known, represents the Prosperous Justice Party (PKS).

Just days before the vote, Aher signed a deal with hardline Islamic Defenders Front (FPI) in which he agreed to implement a ban of the Ahmadiyah sect and generally "maintain an Islamic environment" if re-elected, BeritaSatu reported.

As governor, he is obliged to meet with any citizen group, he told the news outlet, denying further reports that he agreed to issue Sharia-based laws.

A crucial concern

Sukardi Ahmad, a 45-year-old resident of Bogor, West Java, has concerns about religious violence in the region. "Whoever wins the race will have to improve tolerance in West Java," he told Khabar Southeast Asia on voting day, the 24th.

"Last year and this year have been hard times for us as," he said. "February last year, we had 50 people vandalize the Nur Hidayah Mosque in Cianjur initially used by Shia members, followed by the church attacks with 20 gunshots in Indramayu a month later."

Sukardi also mentioned the 2012 Tasikmalaya attacks in which hundreds of FPI members attacked the Mesjid Raya Baiturrahman, a Ahmadiyah mosque, injuring nine people.

"I also witnessed an incident in Bandung last October where FPI damaged the An-Nasir Mosque and also prohibited Ahmadis from celebrating Idul Adha," he continued.

Moreover, since 2008, members of Bogor's GKI Yasmin congregation have held services outside and in private homes, because Mayor Diani Budiarto revoked their church's permit. It has not been restored, despite a Supreme Court ruling in favour of the congregation.

"We are expecting a new governor who is honest and responsible. Corruption in one priority and religious violence is another high priority," University of Indonesia Political Science graduate student Restu Wahyuni told Khabar.

"A newly elected West Java governor should have a real agenda of how to solve religious violence, as it is becoming crucial," she said. "Look how many incidents of terrorism are now linked to West Java."

Running mate helped Aher

Analysts say Aher was helped by his choice of a running mate, well-known actor and director Deddy Mizwar. He appears to have been unscathed, meanwhile, by the late January arrest of his party's president, Luthfi Hasan Ishaaq, on bribery charges.

For a time, Deputy Governor Dede Yusuf appeared to be the race's front runner, but was likely tripped up by a separate corruption scandal that hit the chairman of his camp, the Democratic Party.

The quick count results put him third in the race, behind the pair representing the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (DPI-P), Rieke Diah Pitaloka and Teten Marzuki.

Candidate representatives stressed they were waiting for official results to determine the winner and the possibility of a second round.

The gubernatorial election in Indonesia's most populous province is being closely watched as a harbinger of political trends ahead of the 2014 presidential vote.

Defending the deal

Aher acknowledged his meeting with FPI West Java Chairman Qohhar NZ al-Qodsy in Bandung on February 21st.

"I did not agree to Islamic bylaws, as has been reported," he told BeritaSatu, but he did agree to "maintain the Islamic environment" which already exists in the province.

That means upholding worship practices and the ethics embraced by Muslims, he insisted. "Because the requests were like that, I agreed. But remember, as a state official I have the obligation to protect all citizens as mandated under the Constitution," he said.

As governor, he said, "I fought for every citizen to be equal before the law, regardless of ethnicity, religion, race or group. I respected human rights."

In response to this statement, Political Science student Restu said, "Elections can be tricky and political, but tolerance can go beyond all of this. We should prioritise what people need, and what we want is for everyone to live in tolerance and harmony."

Regardless of who is elected, Sutoro Eko, researcher at Institute of Research and Empowerment, said the winner must take seriously the people's mandate for accountability.

"They are responsible to the people. Democratic processes in the region need to be followed by leadership," he said. "Accountability, transparency, and of course tolerance and harmony are included in this process."

Reader Comments
CLICK HERE to Add a Comment
    • Yaya Suryanata
      March 3, 2013 @ 10:03:47AM
    • Every party cadre works for the glory of their Party and the People of their Party, there has not been any serious leader who puts forward the Entire People of Indonesia.
    • Hakim
      March 3, 2013 @ 10:03:37AM
    • Tolerance is allowed but do not stain religion... Ahmadiah stains the Islam Religion so it is not allowed .. Please take notice...
  • Add A Comment (Comments Policy)* denotes required field



    The Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) does not represent Muslims.

    View Results

    Photo Essay

A woman reacts outside Jakarta's Ritz-Carlton hotel on July 17th, 2009 after bomb blasts tore through it and the nearby JW Marriott. Two suspected Jemaah Islamiyah suicide bombers killed at least six people and injured more than 40 others. [Arif Ariadi/AFP]

    The Global Terror Threat: Southeast Asia

    Southeast Asia has been both a source and a target of global terrorism. Al-Qaeda affiliates Jemaah Islamiyah in Indonesia and Malaysia and Abu Sayyaf in the Philippines are among regional groups that terrorise their home countries with bombings, ambushes,