Touch-screen voting initiated in Bali

A village in western Bali pioneers e-voting in Indonesia as it chooses its village chief.

By Ni Komang Erviani for Khabar Southeast Asia in Jembrana, Bali

August 26, 2013
Reset Text smaller larger

On a bright Monday morning on July 29th, residents of Mendoyo Dangin Tukad, in Jembrana, Bali, lined up to choose their next village chief. Most wore traditional Balinese attire – batik sarongs-- with kebaya for the women and a headscarf (destar) for the men.

  • Election workers assist Wayan Ngidep during e-voting at Mendoyo Dangin Tukad village in Bali on July 29th. [Ni Komang Erviani/Khabar]

    Election workers assist Wayan Ngidep during e-voting at Mendoyo Dangin Tukad village in Bali on July 29th. [Ni Komang Erviani/Khabar]

  • A voter uses touch-screen technology in the village chief election in Mendoyo Dangin Tukad in Jembrana, Bali, on July 29th. [Ni Komang Erviani/Khabar]

    A voter uses touch-screen technology in the village chief election in Mendoyo Dangin Tukad in Jembrana, Bali, on July 29th. [Ni Komang Erviani/Khabar]

The election voting was far from traditional, as election officials said it was the most technologically advanced ever held in Indonesia, using touch-screen devices that verify voters' identity via their national ID cards.

Implementation of the e-voting system was a collaborative effort by the Agency for Assessment and Application of Technology (BPPT) and the Jembrana regional administration. BPPT provided the four e-voting devices, each worth about Rp 10 million ($1,000).

A major breakthrough

The new technology is a breakthrough for Indonesia, which plans to implement it in other parts of the country, according to the head of BPPT, Marzan Iskandar.

"We are very happy the system could be implemented for the first time in Bali, as this will be a pioneer of many other elections. The e-vote village chief election will become a miniature of a system that will be implemented across our country," he said.

All election workers were trained and certified by the BPPT and the Indonesian Technological Auditors Association (IATI), he said. The system prevents any attempt to vote more than once, because voters use their electronic identity card.

"So, no one can manipulate the result," Marzan said.

E-voting is also part of the country's attempt to reduce election costs, and could decrease such costs by nearly 50%, according to Marzan. "It will also cut much time for the vote count process, as well as cut the social cost that can be caused by polling disputes," he added.

Mixed Reactions

Many Mendoyo Dangin Tukad voters appeared sceptical about the new system as they'd never previously voted by computer. Local election committee members patiently guided voters through the process, one-by-one.

"I'd rather vote using ballot papers than using a computer system. It is harder. The traditional system is far easier for me," said 55-year-old voter Wayan Ngidep.

The grandmother of eight had a particularly rough experience when the device she was using malfunctioned. Although election officials helped her navigate through the system, she felt her privacy was breached.

"Everyone finally knew my choice when they tried to help me," Wayan said.

Putu Bukit, 70, had to ask for guidance from her nephew in order to vote. "I don’t understand at all how to use the computer," she said.

But other villagers said it was smooth sailing. "I had no problem in the booth. I think the e-voting system is good," said I Gusti Agung Ayu, 67.

Initial rejection

Voting ended at 2pm, after 1,753 out of 2,381 eligible voters cast their ballots. Candidate number two, IGAK Bambang, won the election with 536 votes, defeating three other rivals.

It was also a victory for local election officials who managed to convince the community to pioneer the system, with the help of promotional programmes and outreach by BPPT and the Jembrana administration.

"It was not easy for me to ensure the local leaders in the village would use the e-voting system. Most of them were worried about the accuracy of the election result," said local election committee chairman I Gusti Putu Suarden.

"The e-voting system was stipulated in Jembrana Bylaw No. 1/2010 on village chief elections. It was our pride to be the pioneer of our national e-voting system," Jembrana Regent I Putu Artha said.

E-voting could be implemented in other elections on the island, even the presidential election, said Ketut Lanang Sukawati Prabawa, chairman of Bali's General Election Commission.

"However, it needs a long preparation time before the system can be implemented all over the country. We should also conduct special programmes for several remote areas across the country, where most of the residents are not able to read," Sukawati said.

Reader Comments
CLICK HERE to Add a Comment
      August 26, 2013 @ 11:08:28AM
    • Now this is what we have been waiting for. If we are to be honest, how many times have we conducted this celebration of democracy in this beloved country. If we play the video, how high has the material cost been and how many lives have been lost for the sake of competing for something because of unbridled desire? It is my hope that voting using a clear touch screen will yield better results with respect to cost and prevention of election disputes between election participants. One thing that comes to mind is that electric power needs to be provided since recently there have been rolling blackouts. I hope Indonesia will always prosper. Thank you.
    • Kohar Suwandi
      August 26, 2013 @ 01:08:13AM
    • Utilizing the advantages of technology for electing local officials or even for the general election is surely more effective and efficient and can prevent cheating. However, this needs to be preceded by the goodwill on the part of those in government to conduct an honest election. If not, there will always be excuses for people's reluctance to use this technology in every election in the future.

Add A Comment (Comments Policy)* denotes required field



The most important issue in Indonesia's presidential election is:

Photo Essay

Mariyah Nibosu, whose husband was shot dead in 2009 by unknown gunmen, stands outside her home in September 2013 in the state-run 'widows' village' of Rotan Batu, 20km from Narathiwat. "Women suffer a lot here," she said. "But we are strong. We have to feed our children by ourselves. We have to survive." [Christophe Archambault/AFP]

As Thailand's Deep South insurgency drags on, families suffer, persevere