In Indonesia, continuing debate over "female circumcision"

The OIC says Islam does not support the practice and the UN has condemned it. What stance will Indonesia take?

By Elisabeth Oktofani for Khabar Southeast Asia in Jakarta

March 05, 2013
Reset Text smaller larger

Despite growing international condemnation of female genital mutilation, the Indonesia Ulema Council (MUI) is urging the government to resist any international or domestic pressure to ban the practice it calls female circumcision.

  • G.K.R Hemas, the queen of Yogyakarta, has urged the government to revoke the 2010 Ministry of Health Regulation that legitimises the practice of female genital mutilation and authorizes medical professionals to perform it. [Elisabeth Oktofani/Khabar]

    G.K.R Hemas, the queen of Yogyakarta, has urged the government to revoke the 2010 Ministry of Health Regulation that legitimises the practice of female genital mutilation and authorizes medical professionals to perform it. [Elisabeth Oktofani/Khabar]

"On the issue of female circumcision, we do not consider it compulsory, but we forbid any action to ban it," MUI Chairman Ma'ruf Amin told a January 21st press conference on the subject at MUI's Central Jakarta office, according to multiple media reports.

He said that in recent times more medical practitioners have refused to perform female circumcisions, and he urged the government to act decisively against such individuals, based on its 2010 Health Ministry regulation on the practice, which effectively legitimises female circumcision and authorise medical professionals to perform it, the Jawa Pos National Network reported.

"Because we support that regulation, we ask the government not to heed any effort by any party that wants circumcision banned in Indonesia," he said, according to Detik News.

"Circumcision is a part of Islamic teaching that is highly recommended for Muslims, whether male or female," he said, adding that the law on the matter calls for specific procedures which, he claimed, do not damage the clitoris.

"The procedure for female circumcision according to Islamic teaching is removal of only the membrane, or in medical terms preputium [the clitoral hood] that covers the clitoris," he said.

"It needs to be understood that Islamic teaching prohibits the female circumcision practice which is done by cutting or injuring the clitoris, as it is dangerous."

Mixed messages

The government has issued mixed messages on female circumcision. In 2006, the Ministry of Health banned it as potentially harmful. But in 2010, it issued guidelines on how the procedure should be done, raising the ire of some women's rights activists.

Gusti Kanjeng Ratu Hemas, the queen of Yogyakarta, believes the government must revoke the 2010 regulation effectively legitimising female circumcision and authorizing medical professionals to perform it.

"I am very certain that the 2010 regulation on female circumcision was issued because there was a big pressure from religious organisations to the Ministry of Health. Even recently, the MUI has demanded the government lift the ban on female circumcision," she told Khabar Southeast Asia.

"I think that all the parties, which are involved, should have a wider point of view on female circumcision, particularly from the health point of view," she said.

It is not known how many Indonesian girls undergo female circumcision, which is believed to reduce sexual desire and prevent promiscuity, and encompasses a wide range of practices in Indonesia, from cutting a small part of the clitoris to scratching it to pressing spices on the genitals.

Suratningtyas, a 46-year-old midwife at a private hospital in Depok, West Java, told Khabar that some parents do ask the hospital for female circumcision.

"I cannot reject their request because we are allowed to do it. But we make sure to do it properly so it will not harm the baby girl," she said.

Condemned by the OIC

At odds with developments in Indonesia, there is growing international consensus against the practice of female genital mutilation.

On December 20th, 2012, the United Nations General Assembly adopted its first-ever resolution on the female genital mutilation, urging states to "take all measures — including legislation — to protect women and girls from this form of violence".

Earlier the same month, speaking in Jakarta at the opening of a conference on women in development, Organisation of Islamic Co-operation (OIC) Secretary General Ekmeleddin Ihsanoglu called on OIC member states to prohibit the practice.

"This practice is a ritual that has survived over centuries and must be stopped, as Islam does not support it," he said, according to reports in OnIslam.net and Tempo. "Female genital mutilation is a violation of human rights of girls and women."

A weak theological basis

The theological basis for female circumcision is a weak hadith, according to Maria Ulfah Anshor, secretary general of Alimat (the Movement for Indonesia Family Justice) and former chairwoman of the woman's wing of Nahdlatul Ulama, Indonesia's biggest Muslim organisation.

"The hadith said that circumcision is sunnah for men [highly recommended] and makrumah for women [voluntary but meritorious]. Hence it cannot be used as a theological basis to conduct female circumcision, because it is optional," she told Khabar.

The government does not need to regulate it, nor should it ban medical professionals from giving the service to a Muslim family that requests it, she said. But she said it is unfortunate that female circumcision is often conducted on infants, meaning that girls have no say in whether they want to undergo an optional practice.

"It is against human rights," she said.

A Javanese tradition

Javanese tradition includes a ceremonial form of circumcision conducted without removing or harming the female body in any way, G.K.R Hemas told Khabar in an exclusive interview.

"Female circumcision in Javanese tradition is very different with what happened in other places. It is done by holding on to a piece of fresh turmeric on female genitals," she said. Later the turmeric and other offerings are thrown to the rivers, she added.

The ceremony is conducted twice, at the age of five and when a girl begins to menstruate. These days, such ceremonies are rarely carried out in Javanese society, except for royal family members at the Yogyakarta sultanate.

"Once again, there is no woman's body part which is being removed or harmed from those two traditions," she added.

Reader Comments
CLICK HERE to Add a Comment
    • andi
      July 12, 2013 @ 08:07:56PM
    • If one of the purposes of female circumcision is to decrease libido, it is tantamount to a violation of human rights.
    • Andi Permana
      May 17, 2013 @ 03:05:16AM
    • The ones who mislead are those who forbid. Jews and Christians will not give any regard to Muslims, unless Muslims abide by them.
    • kimsojn
      April 29, 2013 @ 12:04:50AM
    • a clean men is better
    • indra lesmana
      April 24, 2013 @ 01:04:10AM
    • There is no need for female circumcision.For men it is healthy bacause the person keeps him self more clean with circumcision,
    • sarwar Ali
      April 15, 2013 @ 01:04:09AM
    • There is no need for female circumcision.For men it is healthy bacause the person keeps him self more clean with circumcision,
    • MAL
      April 14, 2013 @ 04:04:32AM
    • "On the issue of female circumcision, we do not consider it compulsory, ....," MUI Chairman The procedure for female circumcision according to Islamic teaching is removal of only the membrane, or in medical terms preputium [the clitoral hood] that covers the clitoris. I think it is the practise that must be changed.... It must be practise PROPERLY.....
    • mungky
      April 5, 2013 @ 12:04:06AM
    • Circumcision for Muslim men is mandatory, whereas for women there is no prohibition, because female circumcision will slightly temper her libido.
    • Ric
      April 2, 2013 @ 10:04:35AM
    • The Creator had created us perfectly as an idividual. WE must decide on what we believe is right for us and not what they believe is right for us.
    • slamet basuki
      March 26, 2013 @ 03:03:50AM
    • I don't like this.
    • sorrow
      March 24, 2013 @ 12:03:22PM
    • to do or not to do is a matter of choice..
    • AAAA
      March 21, 2013 @ 09:03:18AM
    • both male and female circumcision should be banned. not just female circumcision.
    • sulaiman id
      March 14, 2013 @ 11:03:32AM
    • There is no need for female circumcision.
    • ahmad
      March 12, 2013 @ 09:03:03PM
    • Follow the Hadith Sahih, where we can choose which one to do.
    • Didy S
      March 5, 2013 @ 11:03:57PM
    • The Minister of Health and MUI must find a solution, will it be made a misguided polemic...?

Add A Comment (Comments Policy)* denotes required field

Poll

Are extremist groups distorting the true meaning of jihad to recruit fighters for the Syrian civil war?

View Results

Photo Essay

Mariyah Nibosu, whose husband was shot dead in 2009 by unknown gunmen, stands outside her home in September 2013 in the state-run 'widows' village' of Rotan Batu, 20km from Narathiwat. "Women suffer a lot here," she said. "But we are strong. We have to feed our children by ourselves. We have to survive." [Christophe Archambault/AFP]

As Thailand's Deep South insurgency drags on, families suffer, persevere